“I don’t want any Black nurses”: Insights from the Academic Literature and Ontario’s Regulatory Bodies on Navigating Discriminatory Requests/Refusals of Care Providers

Full Title: “I don’t want any Black nurses”: Insights from the Academic Literature and Ontario’s Regulatory Bodies on Navigating Discriminatory Requests/Refusals of Care Providers

Speaker:

Claudia Barned, PhD
Bioethicist – Department of Clinical and Organizational Ethics – University Health Network
Education Investigator 2 – The Institute for Education Research (TIER)
Assistant Professor – Dalla Lana School of Public Health – University of Toronto
Member – Joint Centre for Bioethics – University of Toronto

&

Akosua Nwafor, MHSc (Bioethics)
Department of Clinical and Organizational Ethics – University Health Network

Abstract

Healthcare workers are increasingly exposed to acts of violence, harassment and bigotry from patients, their family members and visitors. When faced with such acts, there is an organizational tendency to rely on zero tolerance policies or make references to applicable guidance from regulatory colleges. The efficacy of zero tolerance policies has been a point of significant debate, as evidence shows very little actualized change at the individual and institutional levels. In addition to the notable disadvantages of zero tolerance policies, they often lack the specificity required for proper support mechanisms and avenues for recourse that provide a sense of justice for the targeted clinician. To complicate matters further, not all regulatory bodies acknowledge or conceptualize discriminatory experiences as ethically problematic practice issues impacting their registrants. As such, healthcare workers can be left to blindly navigate these emotionally distressing encounters and struggle with the tensions between the duty to care and their right to a workplace free from discrimination. This talk critically outlines key findings from the academic literature, most notably, who is often targeted, the types of requests/refusals made, as well as individual and institutional recommendations for change. We will also critically examine the available guidance from 11 of Ontario’s regulatory colleges, noting how they engage [or not] with anti-racism, and issues pertaining to patient bias.

Additional Details:

The event is free and is open to the general public.

The direct link to the seminar will be sent out to registered participants 2 hours before the event. The JCB Bioethics Seminars are now being live-streamed to our YouTube channel. If you don’t receive the link 2 hours before the event, please head over there and click on the live stream. Subscribe to our channel to receive notices of upcoming events.

Questions?

Please email Terry Yuen, jcb.ea@utoronto.ca.